WASHINGTON — It’s one of those words that sounds familiar, you know it’s unfavorable, but you don’t know quite what it means: “sedition.”
Maybe you’re thinking it has something to do with “treason” or “treachery.” Is it an insult? Is it a crime? No doubt some of you learned the word in history class.
Others are learning it from Twitter as lawmakers are being called “seditious” online for publically stating they will refuse to certify electoral votes from certain states on January 6, 2021. Colloquially, they've been dubbed by some as the "Sedition Caucus."
Our Verify researchers spoke with Sai Prakash, Constitutional Law Professor at UVA School of Law; Jeffrey Jacobovitz, litigation partner at Arnall Golden Gregory; and David Benowitz, founding partner at Price Benowitz.
What does sedition mean?
Legally, it carries a different definition.
The U.S. code is pretty specific about what counts as 'seditious conspiracy':
"If two or more persons in any State or Territory, or in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, conspire to overthrow, put down, or to destroy by force the Government of the United States, or to levy war against them, or to oppose by force the authority thereof, or by force to prevent, hinder, or delay the execution of any law of the United States, or by force to seize, take, or possess any property of the United States contrary to the authority thereof...."
"You basically have to conspire to overthrow the United States government through the use of force," Benowitz said. "That's the key, is force."
Benowitz says sedition cases are pretty uncommon because its difficult to meet the "technical requirements of the statute."
Weren't there Sedition Acts throughout U.S. history? Do those still exist?
Prakash explains that in the early 18th century, lots of people were prosecuted under the Sedition Act.
"It was passed during Adam's administration and it made it a crime to bring the Congress or the President into disrepute," Prakash said. "A lot of people were prosecuted under it, but that statute lapsed, it's not longer in our books."
Bringing someone into 'disrepute' is a fancy way of saying you couldn't criticize the government.
"The old act was based on this theory that the government needed the support of the people in order to be viable and health, and that it wouldn't have that support if the people basically dragged the government into the gutter," Prakash said.
During wartime, some presidents chose to renew the act; for instance, our experts said, during WW1.
Today, we don't have a Sedition Act, but "seditious conspiracy" is still on the books.
Is sedition the same as treason? What's the difference?
"Treason goes a step further," Jacobovitz said. "Treason is really looking to overthrow the US government, sometimes it involves foreign defendants, other times it doesn't. But sedition is really a conspiracy to incite some sort of rebellion or incite some sort of action involving the US government."
They're related but different.
"Treason is when you actually make war against the United States or you give aid to an enemy of the United States," Benowitz said.
What do you make of people online calling lawmakers 'seditious?'
Benowitz says it's a figure of speech, they're using it colloquially but that doesn't mean anyone's guilty of seditious conspiracy.
Prakash agrees it's a heftier way to express displeasure.
"People are searching for an adjective and a noun that sounds more weighty than 'this is really wrong and a bad idea,'" Prakash said. "So rather than just saying 'I object to this, this is dangerous, this is playing with fire,' they say things like 'treason' and 'conspiracy'....but it's not a serious claim in any way."
If you have something you want the VERIFY team to look into, email us at firstname.lastname@example.org